diff --git a/src/ProtectedRoomsSet.ts b/src/ProtectedRoomsSet.ts
index 6b564501..9833b876 100644
--- a/src/ProtectedRoomsSet.ts
+++ b/src/ProtectedRoomsSet.ts
@@ -373,6 +373,16 @@ export class ProtectedRoomsSet {
     private async applyUserBans(roomIds: string[]): Promise<RoomUpdateError[]> {
         // We can only ban people who are not already banned, and who match the rules.
         const errors: RoomUpdateError[] = [];
+
+        const addErrorToReport = (roomId: string, e: any) => {
+            const message = e.message || (e.body ? e.body.error : '<no message>');
+            errors.push({
+                roomId,
+                errorMessage: message,
+                errorKind: message && message.includes("You don't have permission to ban") ? ERROR_KIND_PERMISSION : ERROR_KIND_FATAL,
+            });
+        };
+
         for (const roomId of roomIds) {
             try {
                 // We specifically use sendNotice to avoid having to escape HTML
@@ -405,9 +415,13 @@ export class ProtectedRoomsSet {
                         await this.managementRoomOutput.logMessage(LogLevel.INFO, "ApplyBan", `Banning ${member.userId} in ${roomId} for: ${reason}`, roomId);
 
                         if (!this.config.noop) {
-                            await this.client.banUser(member.userId, roomId, memberAccess.rule!.reason);
-                            if (this.automaticRedactGlobs.find(g => g.test(reason.toLowerCase()))) {
-                                this.redactUser(member.userId, roomId);
+                            try {
+                                await this.client.banUser(member.userId, roomId, memberAccess.rule!.reason);
+                                if (this.automaticRedactGlobs.find(g => g.test(reason.toLowerCase()))) {
+                                    this.redactUser(member.userId, roomId);
+                                }
+                            } catch (e) {
+                                addErrorToReport(roomId, e);
                             }
                         } else {
                             await this.managementRoomOutput.logMessage(LogLevel.WARN, "ApplyBan", `Tried to ban ${member.userId} in ${roomId} but Mjolnir is running in no-op mode`, roomId);
@@ -415,12 +429,7 @@ export class ProtectedRoomsSet {
                     }
                 }
             } catch (e) {
-                const message = e.message || (e.body ? e.body.error : '<no message>');
-                errors.push({
-                    roomId,
-                    errorMessage: message,
-                    errorKind: message && message.includes("You don't have permission to ban") ? ERROR_KIND_PERMISSION : ERROR_KIND_FATAL,
-                });
+                addErrorToReport(roomId, e)
             }
         }
 
diff --git a/test/integration/banListTest.ts b/test/integration/banListTest.ts
index 929e1a4a..5bfca29c 100644
--- a/test/integration/banListTest.ts
+++ b/test/integration/banListTest.ts
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 import { strict as assert } from "assert";
 import { newTestUser } from "./clientHelper";
-import { LogService, MatrixClient, Permalinks, UserID } from "matrix-bot-sdk";
+import { LogService, MatrixClient, Permalinks, UserID, MembershipEvent } from "matrix-bot-sdk";
 import PolicyList, { ChangeType } from "../../src/models/PolicyList";
 import { ServerAcl } from "../../src/models/ServerAcl";
 import { getFirstReaction } from "./commands/commandUtils";
@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ import AccessControlUnit, { Access, EntityAccess } from "../../src/models/Access
 import { randomUUID } from "crypto";
 import { MatrixSendClient } from "../../src/MatrixEmitter";
 import { MatrixRoomReference } from "../../src/commands/interface-manager/MatrixRoomReference";
+import { MjolnirTestContext } from "./mjolnirSetupUtils";
 
 /**
  * Create a policy rule in a policy room.
@@ -595,3 +596,44 @@ describe('Test: Creating policy lists.', function() {
         );
     })
 })
+
+describe.only('Test: Continue to ban other marked members when one member cannot be banned', function() {
+    it('Failing to ban a moderator should not stop other members being banned.', async function(this: MjolnirTestContext) {
+        if (this.mjolnir === undefined) {
+            throw new TypeError("Mjolnir was never created.")
+        }
+        const mjolnir: Mjolnir = this.mjolnir;
+        const moderator = await newTestUser(this.config.homeserverUrl, { name: { contains: "mx-moderator" } });
+        await moderator.joinRoom(mjolnir.managementRoomId);
+        const mjolnirId = await mjolnir.client.getUserId();
+
+        const protectedRoom = await moderator.createRoom({ invite: [mjolnirId], preset: 'public_chat'});
+        await mjolnir.client.joinRoom(protectedRoom);
+        await moderator.setUserPowerLevel(mjolnirId, protectedRoom, 100);
+        await mjolnir.addProtectedRoom(protectedRoom);
+
+        const banListId = await moderator.createRoom({ invite: [mjolnirId] });
+        await mjolnir.client.joinRoom(banListId);
+        await mjolnir.policyListManager.watchList(MatrixRoomReference.fromRoomId(banListId));
+
+        await mjolnir.protectedRoomsTracker.syncLists();
+
+        const spamUser = await newTestUser(this.config.homeserverUrl, { name: { contains: "mx-spammer" } });
+        const rudeUser = await newTestUser(this.config.homeserverUrl, { name: { contains: "mx-rude" } });
+        const sillyModerator = await newTestUser(this.config.homeserverUrl, { name: { contains: "mx-moderator" } });
+        await Promise.all([spamUser, rudeUser, sillyModerator].map(c => c.joinRoom(protectedRoom)));
+        await moderator.setUserPowerLevel((await sillyModerator.getUserId()), protectedRoom, 100);
+
+        await createPolicyRule(moderator, banListId, RULE_USER, '@*mx*:*', "don't like them go away.");
+        await mjolnir.protectedRoomsTracker.syncLists();
+
+        const roomMembers = await moderator.getRoomMembers(protectedRoom);
+
+        const assertMembership = (userId: string, membership: string, members: MembershipEvent[]) => {
+            assert.equal(members.find(e => e.stateKey === userId)?.membership, membership);
+        };
+
+        assertMembership(await spamUser.getUserId(), 'ban', roomMembers);
+        assertMembership(await rudeUser.getUserId(), 'ban', roomMembers);
+    })
+})