* Notes on wht to do
- Should targetLayers be altered while doing opportunistic locking
- Should targetLayers be altered in any other path than stream allocator path?
- Lock to layer as long as it is <= opportunistic layer
- When not congested, opportunistic can be highest
- When congested, opportunistic could be nil or lowest if paused is not allowed
- When muting, can we hold on to current layers (or keep it as previous) and
restore on unmute.
- Store current/target in forwarder state and restore on seeding
- Watch for looking for targetLayers, etc. when looking to insert padding
packets. There may be an assumption about restarting on key frame and hence
okay to insert padding when target layers are invalid. This may not be true
any more when doing opportunistic forwarding.
- Can we distinguish between publisher mute or dynacast (i. e. publisher side
stopping) vs subscriber mute and do something useful? Publisher side mute
could mean continuity in sequence numbers on a restart (might be able to
catch it with opportunistic forwarding). But, there is the challenge of
unmute from publisher via signalling channel vs media. If media is arriving,
should subscribers do opportunistic forwarding before publisher mute state
update happens?
- Maybe introduce a mode where forwarding continues to a frame end (of course
with a time limit just in case the end of frame packet is lost) and then
insert silence/padding packets?
- Ensure that audio blank frame insertion does not suffer from frame boundary
issues.
* pub/sub mute separate + more notes on things to check
* WIP commit, more notes
* WIP commit
* WIP commit
* WIP commit
* WIP commit
* WIP commit
* WIP commit
* clean up
* slightly better comments
* Do not stop on unmute
* do not inject blank frames when pub muted
* do not forward on audio publisher mute
* Add Timer to detect dtls failure quickly
* Fix pc state check in timeout after ice
* More strict conditions to switch candidate type
* log for signal interuppt
* typo
* Ignore inactive media.
Seeing some errors of
"track info not published prior to track".
Happens when trying to configure publisher answer for audio
for DTX and stereo and trying to find a pending track.
There are cases where there are inactive m-lines in SDP
that is hitting this.
* fix sense
* Use purely RR based RTT.
With normalization of NTP time stamp to local time,
don't need to keep track of NTP time of publisher + local time of
when a report is sent. RTT calculations can happen with RR only.
Also, do not log errors when RTT cannot be calculated due to
no last SR. This can happen if the receiver sends an RR before
it receives an SR. As SFU is doing SRs once in 5 seconds, it is
possible some RRs happen before the first SR.
* use error type
* correct error name
It's not always possible for WebSocket clients to obtain status code or
error messages returned during WS Upgrade. Moving autocreation validation
to an explicit interface in the validation step so the /rtc/validate
would be able to return an appropriate message.
When AdaptiveStream is enabled, default the subscriber to LOW quality stream
we would want LOW instead of OFF for a couple of reasons
1. when a subscriber unsubscribes from a track, we would forget their previously defined settings
depending on client implementation, subscription on/off is kept separately from adaptive stream
So when there are no changes to desired resolution, but the user re-subscribes, we may leave stream at OFF
2. when interacting with dynacast *and* adaptive stream. If the publisher was not publishing at the
time of subscription, we might not be able to trigger adaptive stream updates on the client side
(since there aren't any video frames coming through). this will leave the stream "stuck" on off, without
a trigger to re-enable it
Sometimes the initial selected node could fail. In that case, we'll give it a few more attempts to locate a media node for the session instead of failing it after the first try.
Added a new manager to handle all subscription needs. Implemented using reconciler pattern. The goals are:
improve subscription resilience by separating desired state and current state
reduce complexity of synchronous processing
better detect failures with the ability to trigger full reconnect
* Use local time base for NTP in RTCP Sender Report for downtracks.
More details in comments in code.
* Remove debug
* RTCPSenderReportInfo -> RTCPSenderReportDataExt
* Get rid of sender report data pointer checks
From logs, can see when reference layer is out of order, it is
out of order by a small amount most of the time (saw a maximum
of 5 ms in a sampling of logs). When using arrival time in those
case, some times the offset comes out to 10 ms or so. In most
of the cases, the time based diff is a lot higher (by several ms).
Just use the default of +1 diff on switch layer in case of
out-of-order time stamp. That will allow playback to move
forward and keep the timing close to actual frame time.
* add prometheus stats for rtt/jitter/packet loss
* add track source to metrics
* better packet loss bins
* add track type to metrics
* remove source from AnalyticsStat
* regenerate telemetry service fake
* compute loss from per stream packet count
Added a flag to throttle dynacast messages to the publisher.
Added a helper method to check if a client supports setting `active`
field in RTP sender encoding. This can be used to disable dynacast based
on some other feature flag/config settings.
* some additional logging
* Do not use local time stamp when sending RTCP Sender Report
As local time does not take into account the transmission delay
of publisher side sender report, using local time to calculate
offset is not accurate.
Calculate NTP time stamp based on difference in RTP time.
Notes in code about some shortcomings of this, but should
get better RTT numbers. I think RTT numbers were bloated because of
using local time stamp.
Related to livekit/protocol#273
This PR adds:
- ParticipantResumed - for when ICE restart or migration had occurred
- TrackPublishRequested - when we initiate a publication
- TrackSubscribeRequested - when we initiate a subscription
- TrackMuted - publisher muted track
- TrackUnmuted - publisher unmuted track
- TrackPublish/TrackSubcribe events will indicate when those actions have been successful, to differentiate.
* Fix handling of non-monotonic timestamps
Timed version is inspired by Hybrid Clock. We used to have a mixed behavior
by using time.Time:
* during local comparisons, it does increment monotonically
* when deserializing remote timestamps, we lose that attribute
So it's possible for two requests to be sent in the same microsecond, and
for the latter one to be dropped.
To fix that behavior, I'm switching it to keeping timestamps to consolidate
that behavior, and accepting multiple updates in the same ms by incrementing ticks.
Also using @paulwe's idea of a version generator.
* initial commit
* add correct label
* clean up
* more cleanup on adding stats
* cleanup
* move things to pub and sub monitors, ensure stats are correctly updated
* fix merge conflict
* Fix panic on MacOS (#1296)
* fixing last feedback
Co-authored-by: Raja Subramanian <raja.gobi@tutanota.com>
* WIP commit
* comment
* clean up
* remove unused stuff
* cleaner comment
* remove unused stuff
* remove unused stuff
* more comments
* TrackSender method to handle RTCP sender report data
* fix test
* push rtcp sender report data to down tracks
* Need payload type for codec id mapping in relay protocol
* rename variable a bit
David Zhao