The token's exp claim and the renewal schedule derive from the same
value, so the flat 60 s RENEWAL_BUFFER was the entire margin between
proactive re-auth and the broker enforcing exp on the live session -
one failed renewal attempt (60 s throttle) or a minute of clock skew
lost the race, seen as clean-FIN disconnects (tls=0x8008) on the waev
preset, whose 55-minute tokens are the only ones short enough to hit
enforcement. Buffer is now lifetime/10 clamped to [60 s, 300 s], and
the disconnect-now threshold uses the same value so every renewal is
a proactive reconnect on the device's schedule; waev re-auths 10 min
before its real 60-minute TTL with ~5 retry windows.
Document why waev's preset claims 3300 s against the broker's real
3600 s TTL: the 5-minute claim-side gap protects token acceptance
against fast device clocks, which the renewal buffer cannot do.
A CONNACK alone reset the backoff ladder, so a flapping broker (accepts
then drops within seconds) retried at the 10 s rung forever - each
attempt a full ~40 KB TLS session alloc/free on internal heap, a known
fragmentation driver. The ladder now clears only after the connection
survives 2 minutes (at least one 75 s keepalive round-trip); flapping
endpoints degrade to the 300 s rung and then the existing 30-minute
circuit-breaker probes, and recover automatically once stable.
The precompiled IDF 4.4 WebSocket transport (libtcp_transport.a) has an
off-by-one in ws_connect(): when a wss:// endpoint answers the upgrade
request with >=1024 bytes of HTTP response before the blank-line
terminator (typical of a down broker behind a proxy serving a large
error page), it writes a NUL one byte past the 1024-byte ws->buffer.
Heap poisoning catches the clobbered tail canary (0xbaad5678 ->
0xbaad5600) only when the block is freed in ws_destroy() during
esp_mqtt_client_destroy() - i.e. MQTTBridge::end() - so a single down
broker made every deferred 'ota update' panic and reboot at teardown,
before the download started. Decoded from a Heltec V3 crash backtrace
on v1.16.0.11; line numbers match ESP-IDF release/v4.4 exactly.
The transport code ships precompiled, so patch at link time instead:
[esp32_base] wraps esp_transport_ws_init and the wrapper swaps the
fresh buffer for a (WS_BUFFER_SIZE + 1)-byte allocation, making the
out-of-bounds index land on owned memory. The oversized handshake then
fails cleanly instead of corrupting the heap. Pass-through on IDF 5.x,
where upstream already fixed it; delete with the Arduino core 3.x move.
Verified: wrap resolves from ESP32WsTransportFix.cpp.o in the observer
firmware.map; observer, room-server observer and plain repeater ESP32
targets build. RAK_4631_repeater failure is pre-existing (reproduced
on the merge base without these changes).
esp-mqtt's default message_retransmit_timeout is 1000 ms: any unacked QoS 1 PUBLISH is resent (byte-identical, DUP=1) every second until the PUBACK arrives or the outbox entry expires (30 s). Status messages are the only QoS 1 publishes; on a congested or recovering uplink where broker acks take several seconds, each 5-minute /status was delivered ~6 times, ~1 s apart, as exact copies (same timestamp and stats). Downstream observers flagged excessive_packet_copies and at least one broker treats it as abuse.
Expose message_retransmit_timeout via PsychicMqttClient and set it to 15 s in optimizeMqttClientConfig: one retry still fits inside the 30 s outbox expiry, preserving at-least-once delivery while capping duplicates at one.
/packets paths are QoS 0 and were never affected.
esp-mqtt's default message_retransmit_timeout is 1000 ms: any unacked QoS 1
PUBLISH is resent (byte-identical, DUP=1) every second until the PUBACK
arrives or the outbox entry expires (30 s). Status messages are the only
QoS 1 publishes; on a congested or recovering uplink where broker acks take
several seconds, each 5-minute /status was delivered ~6 times, ~1 s apart,
as exact copies (same timestamp and stats). Downstream observers flagged
excessive_packet_copies and at least one broker treats it as abuse.
Expose message_retransmit_timeout via PsychicMqttClient and set it to 15 s
in optimizeMqttClientConfig: one retry still fits inside the 30 s outbox
expiry, preserving at-least-once delivery while capping duplicates at one.
/packets paths are QoS 0 and were never affected.
Merges three stacked PRs in one push so the rolling release only builds
the final state:
#20 — Complete observer settings migration and upstream-seam cleanup
- Implement the missing one-time /com_prefs -> /mqtt_prefs observer
settings migration (silent data loss on upgrade before this).
- Harden /mqtt_prefs into a versioned format (magic + version +
payload_len header); legacy headerless layouts detected by size and
migrated once. Drop vestigial _legacy_* fields.
- Deployed flex layout pinned by static_assert (Legacy6SlotMQTTPrefs ==
2904 bytes); verified with the host migration harness and on-device
(Heltec V4: presets, WiFi, and origin survive upgrade and reboot).
#21 — Restore upstream duty-cycle enforcement and CAD
- Restore Dispatcher/StaticPoolPacketManager verbatim from upstream/dev
(token-bucket duty cycle, CAD interface); re-apply the MQTT radio
watchdog as pure additions behind WITH_MQTT_BRIDGE.
- Restore cad_enabled and radio_fem_rxgain persistence at upstream's
/com_prefs offsets (byte-parity with upstream, tail 3 -> 5 bytes).
- Add RxReservePacketManager for observer builds: priority-aware shed +
30s stale expiry so heavy throttling can't park the packet pool and
make the node un-administrable.
- Device-confirmed on Heltec V4.2: throttling holds at set dutycycle 1
on a busy mesh, CAD persists across boots, capture continues at full
rate under throttle.
#22 — Drive LoRa FEM RX gain from radio_fem_rxgain
- MainBoard gains setLoRaFemLnaEnabled/canControlLoRaFemLna/
isLoRaFemLnaEnabled; wired for heltec_v4, heltec_t096, and
tracker_v2. radio.fem.rxgain CLI gated on board capability.
- Persisted pref applied at app startup; defaults ON (upstream parity),
so LNA-capable boards gain RX boost on upgrade.
- Guard path device-confirmed on V4.2 (GC1109, PA-only: reports
unsupported). LNA toggle on V4.3/KCT8103L pending hardware.
Multi-hour soak on the full stack: no memory issues or regressions.
Duty-cycle throttling, CAD-under-load, capture decoupling, remote admin under
throttle, and radio-watchdog fire/recover all device-confirmed on a Heltec
V4.2 (busy mesh + off-frequency bench). Notes the watchdog observability
gotchas found during testing: silent on release builds (check stats-radio-diag
err_flags bit 8) and armed only after first radio activity.
Device testing at 'set dutycycle 1' on a busy mesh showed the node becoming
un-administrable within ~2 minutes: the shed policy dropped its own CLI
responses along with repeats, and parked retransmissions (which never expire)
absorbed every budget refill.
RxReservePacketManager now sheds by priority below the RX reserve — only
pri > 1 outbound (multi-hop flood repeats, adverts, trace) is refused, so the
node's own responses/ACKs (pri 0) and login/PATH replies (pri 1) still queue;
below an emergency floor (reserve/2) everything is shed to protect capture.
Queued packets untransmitted 30 s past their scheduled time are expired at
dequeue via a pointer-keyed age table (the pool is a fixed set of packets, so
pool_size slots cover every key). Under normal load the queue drains in
milliseconds and neither policy triggers.
Load-testing the restored token bucket at 'set dutycycle 1' showed MQTT
capture dropping to exactly the TX rate. Queued retransmissions hold static-
pool packets with no expiry, so throttling parks the whole pool in the send
queue; Dispatcher::checkRecv() then discards received packets before logRx()
ever feeds the bridge — each completed TX frees exactly one packet for
exactly one more RX.
Observer builds now use RxReservePacketManager (fork-owned header): once the
free pool drops below a quarter of the pool, outbound packets are refused and
freed, so RX allocation and MQTT capture continue at full rate while the node
sheds repeat load it has no TX budget for anyway. Non-observer builds keep
upstream pool behavior via the same factory; StaticPoolPacketManager stays
byte-identical to upstream.
companion_radio has its own NodePrefs without radio_fem_rxgain (matching
upstream, which doesn't wire companion either), so the startup call added in
e905451d broke every companion build:
MyMesh.cpp:973: error: 'struct NodePrefs' has no member named 'radio_fem_rxgain'
It went unnoticed behind the pre-existing companion build failures.
Also port upstream's FEM LNA overrides for heltec_t096 and heltec_tracker_v2
verbatim (board overrides + isLNAEnabled/const getters), so all three boards
upstream wires now match instead of reporting unsupported. Both variant files
compile; those targets still fail overall on the pre-existing non-observer
MQTT-source build-config issue (unchanged with this work stashed).
performChannelScan was restored as protected non-virtual but upstream declares
it public virtual — match upstream verbatim so the hunk disappears from the
merge surface. Also replace the bare 'extra > 5' tail threshold with
COM_PREFS_TAIL_BYTES, tied by comment to the trailing writes in savePrefs(),
so the next upstream field append updates one named constant.
The unknown-version path kept defaults at boot but any later savePrefs()
(every CLI set command) rewrote /mqtt_prefs as v1 with defaults, destroying
the newer config after a firmware downgrade. Latch _mqtt_prefs_hold when an
unsupported version is seen and refuse to write while it is set — checked
before the NRF52/STM32 open path, which deletes the file first.
Also pin the frozen legacy /mqtt_prefs layouts (472/1464/2904 bytes + 8-byte
header) with static_asserts so every target build re-verifies the deployed
fleet's file offsets, and null-check _obs in AlertReporter::onLoop.
Completes the FEM RX-gain restoration begun in the CAD/prefs change, which
persisted radio_fem_rxgain but didn't yet drive the hardware. Also dropped
by the 22eb9b87 revert; restored to match upstream.
- MainBoard: setLoRaFemLnaEnabled()/canControlLoRaFemLna()/isLoRaFemLnaEnabled()
virtuals (default: can't control — non-FEM boards report unsupported)
- heltec_v4: board overrides driving loRaFEMControl; LoRaFEMControl gains the
isLNAEnabled() getter (it already tracked lna_enabled and drove the FEM)
- CLI: `set radio.fem.rxgain on/off` / `get radio.fem.rxgain` (guarded by
canControlLoRaFemLna, so it reports "unsupported" on non-FEM boards)
- app startup applies the persisted pref: board.setLoRaFemLnaEnabled(
_prefs.radio_fem_rxgain), beside setRxBoostedGainMode
Default is ON (upstream), so on FEM boards the LNA is enabled after upgrade —
a real reception behavior change to confirm on hardware. The other FEM
variants (heltec_t096/tower_v2/tracker_v2) need the same small board-override
addition; until then `radio.fem.rxgain` reports unsupported there (no
regression — status quo).
Builds: heltec_v4 repeater-observer + room-observer (FEM board), Heltec_v3
repeater (non-FEM, base virtuals no-op). NEEDS on-device validation on a
Heltec V4.
Continues restoring features dropped by the 22eb9b87 revert. Both were
upstream-tested code, not intentional fork removals.
CAD (hardware Channel Activity Detection / listen-before-talk before TX),
fully restored and functional:
- NodePrefs.cad_enabled + `set cad on/off` / `get cad` CLI (default off)
- RadioLibWrapper: _cad_enabled + setCADEnabled() + the scanChannel()/CAD
branch in isChannelActive() (Phase 1 already restored the Dispatcher hook)
- getCADEnabled() overrides in the repeater/room/sensor apps (return the
pref) and companion (always on, matching upstream)
radio_fem_rxgain: the NodePrefs field + /com_prefs persistence are restored
here at upstream's exact offsets (293 fem, 294 cad), which makes /com_prefs
byte-identical to upstream through the tail. The field is persisted and
defaults on (upstream default), but the per-board LNA *driving* + the
`radio.fem.rxgain` CLI are deferred to the FEM-hardware change (they depend
on board methods and want per-board bench testing).
The new-format /com_prefs tail grows from 3 to 5 bytes; the old-format
detection threshold and the host migration harness are updated accordingly
(all scenarios pass, incl. the non-MQTT-build variant).
Builds: Heltec_v3 repeater, repeater-observer, room-observer. (sensor /
plain-room / companion fail only on the pre-existing Timezone.h include
issue, unrelated to these changes.)
Commit 22eb9b87 ("Revert 'Merge remote-tracking branch origin/dev...'")
reverted an entire upstream merge to escape a bad merge state, dropping
860 lines across 66 files. Among the collateral never reconciled on a
later re-merge was eb4fa032's token-bucket duty-cycle enforcement — the
mechanism that keeps nodes under a configured airtime budget (and EU
868 MHz nodes under the legally-mandated duty cycle). The fork had fallen
back to fixed per-packet spacing (getAirtimeBudgetFactor reverted to 2.0),
losing the windowed enforcement.
This was never an intentional design choice, so restoring it re-aligns the
fork with upstream and REDUCES the merge-conflict surface: Dispatcher.{h,cpp}
now diverge from upstream by watchdog additions only (77 insertions, 0
deletions) instead of rewriting checkSend()/loop().
Restored from upstream: updateTxBudget/tx_budget_ms/duty_cycle_window_ms/
getRemainingTxBudget/getDutyCycleWindowMs and the windowed budget logic in
Dispatcher; getOutboundTotal() and the 0xFFFFFFFF count-all sentinel in
StaticPoolPacketManager; the getOutboundTotal() call in StatsFormatHelper.
Re-applied the fork's MQTT radio-watchdog on top as pure additions
(#ifdef WITH_MQTT_BRIDGE), keeping formatRadioDiag.
Stored airtime_factor settings keep their meaning: fork's t*factor spacing
and upstream's 1/(1+factor) windowed budget yield the same steady-state
duty cycle; upstream additionally allows short bursts within the window.
Phase 2 (CAD / radio_fem_rxgain, which touch NodePrefs persistence and
per-board FEM wiring) is documented in RESTORE_UPSTREAM_NOTES.md, not done
here. Builds: Heltec_v3 observer + plain repeater. NEEDS ON-DEVICE
duty-cycle validation before merge.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The /mqtt_prefs format was detected purely by struct size, which is fragile
(size collisions across eras) and forced the vestigial `_legacy_*` fields to
be retained forever to preserve byte offsets. With ~several thousand observer
devices deployed from the rolling `observer-mqtt-latest` flasher, this is the
last safe moment to fix it before the observer-settings split ships.
/mqtt_prefs now leads with an 8-byte MQTTPrefsHeader (magic {0xF5,'M','Q','P'},
version, payload_len) followed by the raw payload. The magic's non-ASCII lead
byte cannot collide with a legacy file (whose payload starts with the
mqtt_origin string), so versioned and headerless files are cleanly separable.
An unrecognized (newer) version leaves the file untouched and falls back to
defaults rather than misreading it.
MQTTPrefs is compacted: the six `_legacy_*` fields are removed. Every deployed
headerless layout — pre-slot (OldMQTTPrefs), 3-slot (ThreeSlotMQTTPrefs), and
the shipped 6-slot flex layout (new Legacy6SlotMQTTPrefs) — is field-copied
into the compact struct and re-saved with the header once, on first boot.
Future fields append to the payload and stay backward compatible.
Verified with a host harness that generates a byte-exact deployed flex
/mqtt_prefs (the flex MQTTPrefs is confirmed identical to Legacy6SlotMQTTPrefs,
2904 bytes) and round-trips it through the new load path, plus pre-slot/3-slot
migration, unknown-version safety, magic/origin collision-safety, and the
combined /com_prefs observer-tail recovery. Observer + room-server + no-MQTT
ESP32 targets build.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The Files section (source layout, upstream integration seams, and
on-device settings migration) is developer-facing detail that sat near
the top of the otherwise user-facing MQTT_IMPLEMENTATION.md. Move it to
a new MQTT_INTERNALS.md and link it from the bottom of the main doc.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The NodePrefs->MQTTPrefs split (2eb41bae) left the promised one-time
migration of the old /com_prefs trailing block unimplemented, so users
upgrading an observer node silently lost SNMP, radio-watchdog, and
fault-alert configuration (alerts reset to off; PSK/hashtag/region wiped).
loadPrefsInt now detects an old-format /com_prefs by its size, skips the
legacy zero-filled MQTT gap (6-slot or 3-slot era), and recovers the
trailing observer block into a LegacyObserverTail (reusing the old
firmware's byte291/292 heuristic and per-field availability guards).
loadMQTTPrefs applies those values when the loaded /mqtt_prefs predates
the appended observer fields, and both files are rewritten once in the
current layout. rx_boosted_gain/flood_max_* are also recovered from the
correct offsets (previously read from inside the old gap and reset).
Verified with a host-side harness that round-trips the real old-firmware
savePrefs (from 2eb41bae^) through the new load path across upgrade,
fresh-install, upstream-format, 3-slot-era, truncated, and legacy-variant
cases, plus a non-MQTT-build variant. Updates the stale migration comments
and documents the CommonCLI_Observer seam in MQTT_IMPLEMENTATION.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Updated MQTT configuration to succeed when port is defined in mqttN.server but not explicitly set in mqttN.port. Updated documentation to specify that when a full
URL with a scheme is provided, the port setting is optional. Added an
example for local development using a plain WebSocket URL, enhancing
clarity for users configuring custom MQTT brokers.
Refactored the handling of observer-related settings by moving them from
NodePrefs to a new MQTTPrefs structure. This change centralizes MQTT,
WiFi, timezone, SNMP, and alert configurations, improving code organization
and maintainability. The new structure allows for better separation of
concerns and prepares the codebase for future enhancements.
Refactored the CommonCLI class to separate observer-related command
handling into CommonCLI_Observer.cpp. This change improves code
organization and maintainability by isolating MQTT, WiFi, and other
observer-specific commands from the main CLI logic.
Improved error handling in the MQTT client to log specific reasons
for connection refusals, including detailed return codes. This change
ensures that users are informed of authentication issues and server
availability problems, enhancing the debugging experience.
Remove unused MQTTMessageBuilder members (getPacketTypeString,
formatTimestamp/Time/Date stubs, JSON_BUFFER_SIZE constant) for a
small flash saving with no behavior change.
Replace the per-byte snprintf("%02X") in bytesToHex with a nibble
lookup table, avoiding a format-string parse up to ~512x per publish
on the MQTT task. Output is byte-for-byte identical uppercase hex.
Implemented new commands for configuring and diagnosing NTP server
settings in the MQTT bridge. Users can now set a custom NTP server
and probe connectivity to configured servers. This enhancement
improves time synchronization reliability for JWT authentication
and provides better diagnostics for NTP connectivity issues.
Updated the build-observer-firmwares workflow to exclude .partsig files
when uploading release assets. This change prevents issues with the
slim-manifest generator and ensures that only relevant firmware files
are published, improving the integrity of the release process.
Implemented functionality to generate and compare partition-table
signatures during OTA updates. This enhancement ensures that the
target build's partition layout matches the device's actual layout,
improving the reliability of OTA updates and preventing issues
related to partition changes.
Updated the otaFromManifestImpl method to enhance the display of
available and current firmware versions. The changes ensure that
the short commit hash is included in the status messages,
providing clearer versioning information during OTA checks.
Improved the otaFromManifestImpl method to handle dry run scenarios
by allowing HTTP fetches without TLS, reducing heap usage on no-PSRAM
boards. This change ensures better compatibility and reliability during
OTA checks while maintaining security for actual updates.
Enhanced the firmware versioning system by appending a build number
suffix when available, allowing for better tracking of published builds.
This change improves the OTA update process by providing clearer
versioning information in the embedded firmware string.
Added support for deferred OTA updates in the MyMesh class, allowing
the system to schedule firmware updates to occur after a confirmation
reply is sent. This change improves the user experience by ensuring
that the update process does not block the main application loop,
allowing for smoother operation during firmware updates.
Updated the startOTAUpdate method to serve the ElegantOTA on the
station IP when connected to a WiFi network, enhancing accessibility
for OTA updates. If not connected, it defaults to the MeshCore-OTA
SoftAP. This change improves the user experience by allowing easier
access to OTA updates without needing to switch networks.
Updated the otaFromManifest method to stream-parse the firmware manifest
directly from the network, reducing peak RAM usage during OTA checks. This
change enhances compatibility with slow TLS links by implementing a per-read
timeout, ensuring a more efficient and reliable update process.
Updated the otaFromManifest method to enforce HTTP/1.0 for better
compatibility with CDNs and to handle empty manifest responses. This
ensures that the JSON parser receives a complete body, preventing
errors during firmware update checks.
Added functionality to support pull-based OTA updates by fetching firmware
from a manifest. The new `otaFromManifest` method allows the system to
check for available updates and flash the firmware if necessary. This
enhancement improves the update process for observer builds using the
MQTT bridge, ensuring a more seamless firmware management experience.
agessaman